Review of the Fujitsu LifeBook P-2046 - First Impressions
Very excitedly yesterday I opened my birthday present to myself – a brand new
Fujitsu P-Series LifeBook P-2046. I have been looking for a suitable, lightweight machine for writing and other odds and ends. I began my search with the Sony Vaio
PictureBook at the high end, or a Toshiba Libretto 150CT (used) at the low end. Trolling various retail, review, and auction websites, I found myself led to the Fujitsu. This machine is simply amazing. First, let me give a little rundown of its chief features:
- Transmeta Crusoe 800 Mhz processor
- 256MB RAM
- 20GB disk
- DVD / CD-RW drive, built-in
- 7 hour battery life with the extended battery I bought (3.5 hour normal battery life, up to 14 hours with two extended batteries)
- 2 USB ports
- 1 FireWire IEEE-1394 port
- 1 S-Video output port
- 1 Type II PCMCIA port
- External USB floppy drive
- 1280 x 768 @ 16 million color internal display (half-height as is typical of this form factor)
- 802.11b wireless interface
- 56k modem built-in
- 10/100 Ethernet wired port built-in
- Windows XP Professional installed
- Trackpoint-style mouse/pointer
- Headphone, microphone, and line out ports
- Micro-VGA out port, with adapter
- InterVideo (link) WinDVD software, etc.
As described above, it comes to about $1900 new, not including tax and shipping. A really amaazing deal. Oh, and did I mention that it only weighs about 3.4 lb!! A similarly configured Sony would add about $1000, and require extra cables and external peripherals. Further, the top Sony only has the 733 Mhz Crusoe chip.
The machine is beautiful. It has clean, unadorned lines, in a simple silver/titanium color. A gunmetal-blue LifeBook logo on the top gives it a sharp, distinctive appearance. The wi-fi unit sits on the left side of the display and is unobtrusive. Overall, the machine feels solid, and quite respectable. The machining and workmanship seem impecable. 3.4lb is both lighter and more substantial than I expected. The battery seems to take up the largest single chunk of that weight, so if you can deal with the normal 3.5 hour battery life (which is still very generous – a commute to work and back) you may want to consider sticking with the standard battery. The machine is definitely lighter and less bulky than the Apple PowerBook / Titanium, which I also considered. For all Apple afficianado's extoll the virtues of their light laptops, this Fujitsu wins hands down. All told, the machine is extremely totable, and I intend on having it with me just about all the time.
Getting back to the battery – the extended lithium ion battery gives you about 7 hours of life if you're not using the DVD / CD player. Watching some old
Monty Python on the way in to work this morning saw the battery tick down about 40% over a 65 minute ride. One good thing about the extended battery is that it actually juts out in front of the keyboard just a little to handle the additional capacity. I actually find this nice, as it provides extra room for you to rest your wrists while typing.
The display is very nice. Despite the so-called half-height form factor, for most applications I think you would barely notice. The colors are deep and very smooth for a device of this size and capability. The screen does dim noticeably when you are running on battery. There a brightness settings for the ATI video driver that allow you to adjust the brightness a bit. You cannot achieve the same brightness unplugged as you can with AC, though. It doesn't seem to bother me, but it is something you will notice. One thing to consider is if you will be using the machine outdoors often. The dimness is most noticeable outside, and if writing the great American novel at the beach is your intent, this display may not be right for you. A minority of reviewers on
CNet commented that theirs came with dead pixels. Mine has no such unfortunate artifacts..
So far, all I have installed are WinDVD,
OpenOffice, and
PaintShop Pro. (link) So far so good. DVD's play smoothly, and make for a nice diversion on the way to work, or maybe even during boring conference sessions. :-) The DVD drive is nice and quiet during movie play, but it was rather loud while I was using it to install some software. If it occurs more frequently I will update this review to indicate any annoyances. One thing about DVD playing, is adjusting the WinXP volume control in the tray seems to make the DVD stutter just a bit. I've only played one DVD so far, so I will have to test further and make sure it wasn't something about that disc.
I am typing this in OpenOffice on the LifeBook, and OpenOffice is running fine. In fact, unscientifically, it seems to be running a bit faster than on my PII 233 Mhz Dell or ThinkPad laptops, and more smoothly than on an old Pentium II MMX 450Mhz clone at home. Not too surprising.
In terms of performance, it's too early to tell. As mentioned above, OpenOffice runs nicely, but a word processor is not the best measure of performance. I will post updates as I get a better feel of this machine's performance. Of the only 9% or so of CNet
reviews that did not give this a thumbs-up, a recurring complaint was speed. One thing I may end up getting my hands on is a copy of
Mathematica, so if I do I will update with some performance figures. Also, this is my first box with XP, so it's unclear to me how much perceived slowness people see is really just a result of code plaque inside XP. Turning off animated menus and other dancing baloney seems to help, but we'll see. Those who know me know that slow machines make me rip my hair out. Anyway, more to come on this point.
OK, down to the brass tacks – annoyances. In no particular order:
- For convenience there are three application launcher-buttons on the face of the machine, at various positions around the display. One is for launching email, and is just to the left of the display. Unfortunately, that's precisely where I find myself grabbing the machine when I move around. Will have to see if that button can be disa bled.
- Audio volume when playing DVD's is too low – even at maximum volume, with either the speakers or the headphones.
- The screen dimming when on battery can be a little annoying in the wrong light. Not a deal breaker, though.
- Windows XP. I don't think I'm going to like it.
- Fujitsu ships using UPS (link) 2nd day air from Osaka, Japan. UPS sucks eggregiously. They regularly deliver next day or 2nd day packages to me in 4-7 days. Unfortunately, many vendors use them exclusively. My machine took 5 days to arrive. The UPS site showed it had been stuck in Anchorage for 2 days and in Kentucky for 2 more. The UPS customer service people are a joke. Useless and obstructionist. Perhaps more in a later rant....
Most surprising things about the Fujitsu P-2046:
- It stays very cool during operation... was able to have the machine on my laptop for an hour of DVD watching and writing and not even be aware of any heat. Totally unlike my Dell and IBM laptops.
- Netscape 6.1 came installed.
- WinDVD did not come installed – had to install that myself with the provided CD-ROM.
Other machines I looked at before deciding on the Fujitsu:
The iBook is too toylike, and PowerBook is too heavy. The Sony is an entirely bad value-for-money proposition. Anyone buying a Sony over a Fujitsu (or over an L3 for that matter) is a fool, IMHO. The Toshiba is comparable price-wise with a similar configuration, but only had the 600Mhz Crusoe, and all of the goodies were external and required cables, etc. But it was very light. The Dell was bland and uninspiring, as was the Compaq. I'm also a fervent hater of glide-point style pointers. The Gateway, glidepoint notwithstanding, was the only other serious contender in the final analysis. Very nice machine, has gotten lots of good reviews. But, heavier, more expensive, and unnecessarily larger form factor.
In conclusion, if you are thinking about getting a subnotebook, or a very light laptop, I urge you to take a peek at the Fujitsu. They have just come out with new models with slightly more processor speed and bigger disk (much to my chagrin :-/ ) without increasing the price. Fujitsu has done a bang-up job on this little box, and you would be doing yourself a disservice to not include them in your analysis.